Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

The Commodore and I decided to partake in an evening showing of Scott Pilgrim a couple of days ago, and we both walked away pleased with the experience.  There were a few things that bothered me a bit.  Michael Cera essentially plays Michael Cera, which grates on me after 2 hours (at least he had some badass moments to break up the high-pitched loser mentality at several points).  The first half hour or so of the movie dragged for me (but held my attention from the first "Evil Ex" battle on - loved all of those, by the way).  And the character of Scott Pilgrim actually rubbed me the wrong way for most of the movie.  Truth be told, he's a bit of a douche - which is hard to root for - but he reached a major revelation by the end that salvaged him somewhat in my eyes.

But that's just the not-so-great stuff.  I found a lot more to like.  The cinematography, choreography, and sound editing were top notch.  I thought the script was well written and funny.  And the supporting cast was very good (special recognition for Knives Chau and Wallace).  Essentially, this is the closest I've ever felt a movie has come to emulating the style of video games, comic books, and various other aspects of geek and (I shudder to say, but must unfortunately include) "hipster" culture.  Unfortunately, that seems to be where the movie has gone wrong at the box office.

After a paltry $10 million opening weekend, I wondered why it had such a poor showing.  And now I know.  It's a great love letter to many people (especially guys) in their teens and 20's, but most everyone outside that demographic will flatly not understand this movie at all.  The sound effects, allusions to comic books (especially manga), and fight scenes taken straight out of some video games will completely fly over the heads of people who are not immersed in that culture.  When we arrived at the theater, there were about 6 people already there (a little awkward, considering they were all couples, but whatever).  Not a large showing, but hey, what do you expect at a Tuesday evening showing?  Anyway, about halfway through, one of the couples walked out.  At least, I don't think they both decided to take the opportunity for an exciting dual trip to the snack bar.  But seriously, I've never walked out on a movie (at the very worst, I fell asleep in the middle of Battlefield Earth).  It's quite a statement to pay your $10 and say, "You know, I find this experience so completely uninteresting that I'm going to eat the cost and go do something else."

These are the people that don't get it.  And won't.  You can try to explain why some things are appealing to people who haven't played Legend of Zelda, or couldn't tell you the first thing about Street Fighter, but it's ultimately futile unless they've been immersed in that culture for at least a few years.  I shudder to think how far my dad would get in this movie before uttering a dismissive "Yak" and moving on to football game or somesuch.  Not that there's anything wrong with that - I don't expect him to understand the themes prevalent, as they weren't around during his formative years.  But for many of us in our teens and 20's, we can appreciate all the nods and effects that invoke the nerd culture of our age.  And I for one really appreciate this mainstream release movie for pushing that culture (kicking and screaming) much to the fore, in what I hope will be its first inroads into real "popular" culture.  But the initial box office returns for this movie tells me how much farther we have to go.

Some people really love this movie, calling it akin to "our generation's Citizen Kane".  I certainly wouldn't go that far, but it's a fun little movie and what it represents to me means a lot more than the sum of its parts.  It's vindication that the so-called "Millennial" generation's underground culture is worthy of serious treatment and is becoming less ignored.  Though initial revenues don't seem to bear that out, this is a first salvo, and I hope that it achieves more success in the after-theater market (which I'm willing to bet will happen).  I could not imagine a movie like this being released 10 years ago, but I'm excited to see what this will inspire for the next decade and beyond.

TommyJames's picture
Offline
Last seen: 9 weeks 4 days ago
Title: Beta Wolf (Moderator)
Joined: 03/15/2010
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

I wanna see this.  It looks like a fun ride.

Hipermusic's picture
Offline
Last seen: 36 weeks 4 days ago
Title: Thief
Joined: 05/30/2010
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

 I really want to see this movie but they in Spain we're not getting it until December....

dragono1130's picture
Offline
Last seen: 5 weeks 1 day ago
Title: Blue Mage
Joined: 05/13/2010
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

funny thing.  I had no interest in this movie originally because I thougt it was going to be very stupid.  After hearing everything about it sounds morei nteresting by the minute. 

Roo
Roo's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 days 6 hours ago
Title: Call me a treasure hunter or I'll rip your lungs out
Joined: 07/09/2009
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

Dragon, let me be clear - it is a pretty stupid movie.   But at the same time it's very entertaining.  As long as you're in the right demographic.

Cin Wicked's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 year 13 weeks ago
Title: Noob and/or likely spambot
Joined: 05/31/2010
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

 What are you talking about Roo? Scott Pilgrim is the movie of this decade of this generation. (That's right Colbert I went there.)

In all seriousness yeah it's pretty goofy but I still liked it (and my now almost pathological need to search for depth in things gave me a bunch of good stuff in this film.)

yeletihw's picture
Offline
Last seen: 50 weeks 4 days ago
Joined: 10/21/2010
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

I loved this movie, and I think you hit it dead-on for why it didn't work at the box office. To be honest, it makes me like it even more because like you said, its speaking to a some what smaller niche in our culture, which gives it more of an intimate experience for me and people like us. Most movies don't really go for that, they just try and make as much money possible by reaching the widest demographic, and props to Scott Pilgrim for not going that route.

VegasAceVII's picture
Offline
Last seen: 14 weeks 4 days ago
Title: Bard
Joined: 10/20/2010
Posts:
Re: Scott Pilgrim vs. The Box Office

 They can count me in for Blu-ray sales.  I'm buying it, I really thought it was a good time.  I think it was supposed to be really ridiculous...lol.

User login
In Association With


 
CotGW's YouTube Channel
CotGW on Twitter CotGW on Facebook